Chess`s global governing body, FIDE, has issued a formal statement addressing the highly publicized situation involving Grandmaster Vladimir Kramnik, Grandmaster David Navara, and the contentious debate surrounding online fair play. The statement outlines FIDE`s position on the matter, its plans for evaluating proposed anti-cheating methodologies, and expresses significant concern over the personal and legal ramifications that have emerged.
Recognizing the paramount importance of fair play in both over-the-board and online chess, particularly given the surge in online activity, FIDE has stated its commitment to seriously consider methods aimed at upholding integrity. GM Vladimir Kramnik has been a vocal proponent of examining statistical patterns to identify potential instances of unfair play and has publicly presented methodologies for this purpose.
FIDE acknowledges that Kramnik`s publicly proposed methods warrant careful review. To facilitate this, the organization plans to establish a dedicated task force specifically tasked with evaluating these approaches. GM Kramnik has been formally invited by FIDE to present the detailed specifics of his methodology and the statistical data supporting his analysis for official evaluation.
However, FIDE`s statement moves beyond a purely technical assessment of detection methods. The governing body expresses “grave concern” regarding the manner in which Mr. Kramnik has presented his points. FIDE asserts that this presentation style is causing considerable harm to the chess community. Coming from a former World Champion, this narrative is considered potentially “ruinous” for the careers and overall well-being of specific individuals.
The discourse has notably impacted GM David Navara, a respected figure within the chess world. The situation has escalated to the point where GM Kramnik has filed a defamation lawsuit against GM Navara.
FIDE strongly emphasizes GM Navara`s character and record, stating that throughout his career, he has cultivated an “unquestionable reputation as a paragon of a fair play.” The organization highlights that the chess community is well aware of Navara`s sensitivity and integrity, making him particularly vulnerable to implications of unfair play.
While refraining from commenting on the legal or stylistic specifics of the statements made by the individuals involved, FIDE prioritizes mutual respect and empathy among chess colleagues. Consequently, FIDE has issued a clear and unequivocal call for the lawsuit filed by GM Kramnik against GM Navara to be withdrawn as swiftly as possible.
This plea is framed as being in the best interest of the entire chess community. FIDE expresses a sincere hope that GM Kramnik will undertake this action, which they describe as a “morally justified step” that is expected to be welcomed broadly by the chess world.
The statement underscores the complex challenge faced by the chess community: balancing the crucial need for robust fair play measures with the imperative to conduct related discussions responsibly and respectfully, avoiding personal damage and legal conflict.
Marcus Blakely 
Gilbert Pendleton